decentralized exchanges allow users to trade cryptocurrencies peer-to-peer (P2P) in a trustless, non-custodial manner.

DEX Update: Regulatory Landscape Changes

In the context of cryptocurrency and blockchain technology, a DEX refers to a decentralized exchange. Unlike centralized exchanges (CEX), where a third party holds and manages users’ funds and transactions, decentralized exchanges allow users to trade cryptocurrencies peer-to-peer (P2P) in a trustless, non-custodial manner.

In a DEX, users remain in control of their private keys and do not have to entrust their assets to a centralized entity. Trades are executed through smart contracts that run on the blockchain network, ensuring that transactions are transparent, immutable, and resistant to censorship. DEXs offer several benefits over centralized exchanges, including improved security, privacy, and transparency. However, they can also have higher fees, lower liquidity, and may require users to have some technical knowledge and access to specific wallets or tools.

Decentralized exchanges (DEXs) have the potential to be used for money laundering, just like any other type of financial service or exchange. The anonymity and decentralized nature of DEXs can make it more difficult to trace transactions and identify the parties involved, which can make them an attractive option for those seeking to launder money or engage in other illicit activities. This has made DEXs a focus of various regulators across the globe.

DEXs are typically designed to operate in a decentralized manner, without any central authority or regulatory oversight. Yet, many promoters have to sought to centralize certain aspects of DEX management as DEXs have become more popular. One particular area of centralization is book management.

Book management on a decentralized exchange (DEX) refers to the management of the order book, which is a list of buy and sell orders that are waiting to be executed. Book management on a DEX involves several tasks, including:

  1. Order Matching: The DEX’s order book must be able to match buy and sell orders according to specific criteria, such as the price and quantity of the orders. The smart contract running on the blockchain is responsible for executing trades based on these criteria.
  2. Order Management: The DEX’s order book must also manage the lifecycle of the orders, including when they are submitted, partially filled, or canceled.
  3. Liquidity Management: The DEX must ensure that there is sufficient liquidity in the order book to enable trades to be executed efficiently. This may involve incentivizing liquidity providers to supply liquidity to the order book.

The use of centralized book management has only served to increase regulatory scrutiny of DEXs. While DEXs can offer users greater privacy and control over their assets, it can also make it more difficult for governments and regulatory agencies to enforce their laws and regulations. However, in some jurisdictions, decentralized exchanges (DEXs) may be required to register as a money service business (MSB) or comply with other financial regulations.

In the United States, for example, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) has issued guidance stating that virtual currency exchanges and administrators, including DEXs, are considered MSBs and must register with FinCEN and comply with AML and KYC requirements. Moreover, some states require cryptocurrency exchanges, including DEXs, to obtain a money transmitter license to operate within their borders, while others do not have specific regulations governing cryptocurrency exchanges.

Similarly, in the European Union, DEXs may be subject to the Fifth Anti-Money Laundering Directive (5AMLD), which requires virtual currency exchanges and custodian wallet providers to register with their national competent authorities and comply with AML and KYC regulations.

The United Kingdom has taken a far more comprehensive approach to regulations. In the United Kingdom, decentralized exchanges (DEXs) and other cryptocurrency businesses are subject to regulation by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), which is the regulatory body responsible for overseeing financial services in the UK.

The regulatory requirements for DEXs in the UK depend on the specific activities being conducted by the exchange and the types of assets being traded. In general, if the assets being traded on a DEX are considered securities under UK law, then the exchange may be subject to additional regulatory requirements. Under the UK’s AML/CFT regulations, DEXs and other cryptocurrency businesses are required to implement measures to prevent money laundering and terrorist financing. This includes conducting customer due diligence (CDD) and reporting suspicious transactions to the appropriate authorities. In 2020, the FCA announced that all cryptocurrency businesses operating in the UK, including DEXs, would be required to register with the FCA and comply with AML/CFT regulations. However, in January 2021, the FCA announced that it would be unable to process new registrations due to a backlog of applications and ongoing concerns around compliance with AML/CFT regulations.

While non-binding as law, the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) has issued guidance and recommendations for decentralized exchanges (DEXs) regarding anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing (AML/CFT) measures. The FATF’s guidance recommends that DEXs be subject to the same AML/CFT requirements as centralized exchanges, including implementing risk-based AML/CFT programs, conducting customer due diligence, and reporting suspicious transactions. Specifically, the FATF recommends that DEXs should:

  1. Conduct Customer Due Diligence (CDD): DEXs should implement policies and procedures for identifying and verifying the identities of their users. This may include collecting information such as name, address, and identification documents.
  2. Implement Risk-Based AML/CFT Programs: DEXs should implement risk-based AML/CFT programs to identify and mitigate the risks of money laundering and terrorist financing on their platforms. This may include implementing transaction monitoring systems, conducting periodic risk assessments, and providing AML/CFT training to staff.
  3. Report Suspicious Transactions: DEXs should have procedures in place for reporting suspicious transactions to the appropriate regulatory authorities. This may include reporting transactions that are unusually large or complex, involve high-risk customers, or are otherwise suspicious.

The nature of tokens traded on a DEX can also invite regulatory scrutiny. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has taken an active role in regulating DEXs. The SEC has indicated that some cryptocurrencies and tokens may be considered securities under US law, and therefore subject to the same regulatory requirements as traditional securities. Accordingly, a DEX that provides for the trading a security tokens would also be subject to the same registration requirements as traditional securities exchanges or Alternative Trading Systems. In addition to the SEC, DEXs may be subject to regulation by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) if they offer cryptocurrency derivatives or other products that are considered commodities.

To date, there have been few direct regulatory actions taken against DEXs, but the volume of ongoing investigations by regulators increasing. Notable enforcement actions against DEXs include:

  1. BitMEX: BitMEX, a cryptocurrency derivatives exchange that operates as a hybrid centralized/decentralized platform, was charged with AML violations by the U.S. Department of Justice in October 2020. The charges alleged that BitMEX violated the Bank Secrecy Act by failing to implement an adequate AML program and failing to implement adequate KYC procedures.
  2. EtherDelta: In November 2018, the founder of EtherDelta was charged by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) with operating an unregistered securities exchange. The SEC alleged that EtherDelta failed to register with the SEC and failed to implement adequate AML and KYC procedures.
  3. Shapeshift: In 2018, Shapeshift, a Switzerland-based cryptocurrency exchange that operates as a DEX, was criticized for its lack of AML/KYC procedures. The exchange subsequently announced that it would begin implementing AML/KYC measures.
  4. Uniswap: In March 2021, it was reported that the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) had opened an investigation into Uniswap, one of the largest decentralized exchanges in the cryptocurrency space. The investigation is reportedly focused on Uniswap’s decentralized governance structure, as well as its trading activities.
  5. BitShares: In February 2019, the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) charged the developers of BitShares, a decentralized exchange, with illegally offering derivatives contracts that were not registered with the CFTC. The CFTC also alleged that the developers failed to implement adequate AML/KYC procedures.

Overall, DEXs are a vital component of the DeFI landscape yet operate in a very grey regulatory environment.

About Adam Tracy

Adam Tracy is a payments expert and entrepreneur who specializes in payment systems, blockchain technology, digital currencies, and other emerging technologies. He is the founder of Blockrunner, LLC that provides consulting services to clients in the blockchain, payments and cryptocurrency arenas.

Tracy has been involved in the blockchain, payments and cryptocurrency space since 2013, and he has worked with a wide range of clients, including startups, established businesses, and investors. He has advised clients on legal and regulatory issues related to initial coin offerings (ICOs), cryptocurrency exchanges, regulatory licensing, smart contracts, and other blockchain applications.

In addition to his consulting work, Tracy has founded several companies in the blockchain and cryptocurrency space, including a digital asset hedge fund and a blockchain-based tokenization platform. He is also a proponent of decentralized finance (DeFi) and has been involved in various DeFi projects.

Tracy is also a frequent speaker and writer on blockchain and cryptocurrency topics. He has been featured in a wide range of publications, including Forbes, CoinDesk, and Bitcoin Magazine.

Find Adam: